Beyond School

. . . and beyond “schooliness” - notes of a 20th c. teaching drop-out

On the Moral Goodness of Smoking and Cheating

with 6 comments

The following is rough transcript of my introductory remarks to two Advanced Placement Literature classes about a month ago.

I have two important announcements. Please pay attention.

One: I’m forming a Smoking on Campus Committee.

I’ve had enough of all the wrong-headed anti-smoking hysteria in our school. Smoking is not a social evil; it’s a social good. The world is over-infested with humans, and any habit that decreases our numbers is a long-term good for the planet. Further, any habit that saves us from the miseries of octogenarian decrepitude - dentures, incontinence, senility, and so forth - should be embraced, not shunned. Therefore, I’m announcing the Smoking on Campus Committee. Our platform consists of, first, promoting the sale of cigarettes and other tobacco products at the student store; and second, asserting students’ rights to smoke in the classroom, hallways, cafeteria, and anywhere else on campus.

Any students interested in applying for leadership positions in this committee are urged to see me after class.

Two: I’m offering One-on-One Conferences in Remedial Cheating

Cheating is an important skill for school. Done successfully, it saves you from wasting hundreds of hours of precious developmental time on mindless homework, and gives you the opportunity to devote that time instead to the pursuit of your own interests: music, sports, real reading and writing, friendship, navel-gazing, sleep, romance, whatever. As a teacher, it is my duty to equip you with the real-world skills you need to succeed. So I want to see the following students, whose plagiarism skills are not adequately fool-proof, for some remedial one-on-one lessons after school: [names withheld].

April Fool’s? Yes, for this post. But not for my class. I really did deliver something like this a few weeks ago, as an introduction to Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest. Rather than try to explain how Wilde’s characters utter the most outrageous, radical things - but with such straight faces that the humor and social criticism go right over the heads of switched-off audiences - I thought I’d attempt to give them a taste of Wilde’s method by making the above announcements with a straight face of my own.

I wish I’d filmed the students’ faces. Typically blank at first - another teacher yammering away - then the eyes get a little wider and more focused; then the glancing at other students with “are you hearing what I’m hearing?” looks. A few students nodding their heads in agreement with my “logic.”

A one-minute discussion of “Why did I make these announcements?” and “Were they entirely ridiculous?” (-”No.” -) “Why not?”, and they were ready to watch Wilde. Here’s a clip from the 1952 film adaptation by Anthony Asquith - as perfect a film as you’ll ever see. Enjoy the (not so) foolishness as the respectable Lady Bracknell interviews “Earnest,” a suitor for her daughter’s hand in marriage :) :

Written by Clay Burell

March 30th, 2008 at 6:31 pm

6 Responses to 'On the Moral Goodness of Smoking and Cheating'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'On the Moral Goodness of Smoking and Cheating'.

  1. Haha! I’d join the smoking club. I just love the jackets.

    What do you think of the more recent film version with Colin Firth?

    Lindsea’s last blog post..?A wickedly funny read?an absolute howl.? ?Daily News

    Lindsea

    30 Mar 08 at 7:31 pm

  2. I’m in on the smoking club. Not for population reducing reasons but for my personal theory that smoking is exercise for the lungs. It forces you to work harder to breath which leads to greater endurance. Really it’s science!

    Charlie A. Roy’s last blog post..Four Steps to More Time Continued…

    Charlie A. Roy

    30 Mar 08 at 9:46 pm

  3. Charlie, Lindsea, your comments are shining examples of the educational value of comments. I’ve added the jackets and exercise arguments to my pitch for smoking on campus the next time I make it :)

    Clay Burell

    31 Mar 08 at 1:09 am

  4. Well, cheating is just the natural extension of the “I don’t have to memorize facts, I can get the information I need online” philosophy.

    Not to mention how damaging to self-esteem low grades are.

    And think of the teacher time freed up by not having to read, comment upon, and grade student work. Why, all the educators could spend those extra hours getting up to speed on educational technology!

    Makes perfect sense: only those who lack the energy & initiative to cheat should fail. No excuse for laziness in the 21st century.

    diane’s last blog post..A Confederacy of Dunces

    diane

    31 Mar 08 at 3:10 am

  5. I”m sorry to notify that I won’t join the smoking club until I graduate cross country :P

    I read The Importance of Being Earnest too as a summer reading assignment for 10th grade, and I didn’t quite recognize its hidden meanings; on the review I just noted how ironic and funny it was. Perhaps because I wasn’t aware of the social background of the time?

    Soojin

    31 Mar 08 at 8:27 am

  6. Soojin,

    Good reason for revisiting literature periodically. I tell this to the younger students that when they check out something like Harry Potter: even if you can read the words, it doesn’t mean that you understand the story, or won’t get more out of it when you’re older.

    A few years ago I revisited many childhood favorites, to see what held up.

    Glad to see that you can make the connections when it comes to athletics & smoking!

    diane

    diane’s last blog post..Letter to the NYS Board of Regents

    diane

    31 Mar 08 at 8:32 am

Leave a Reply

Note: This post is over 4 months old. You may want to check later in this blog to see if there is new information relevant to your comment.