Beyond School

Really. “Schooliness” retards growth.

How They Do Surprise Us, These People We Call Students

with 2 commentsPrint This Post Print This Post


I’m catching up on grading and assessing on my AP Literature Ning - that’s where most assignments are posted, so student-people can see each others’ work, and my replies to everybody, not just to them - and was wowed by JungHee.

How? I assigned Keatsstunning last sonnet, “Bright Star, Would I were Stedfast as Thou Art,” as a four-stage response exercise. Those stages were in four forums:

1. Read the poem and journal your first impressions.
2. Draw the poem’s imagery, then journal how your first impression changed.
3. Record and upload an mp3 of yourself reciting the poem - and read it as well as you can.
4. Journal how reciting and listening to your recital further changed your impressions of the poem.

In short: read it with the switched-off laziness that is par for the course with homework; SEE the imagery (and if you’re really sharp, discover that you can touch those images, hear them, smell them, taste them, too); sing the poem’s sounds (albeit atonally); and connect those sounds to the sense of the poem by hearing them.*

I’m really enjoying reading and replying to these forums. The reflections are so revealing of each student’s level of accomplishment in savoring poetry.

But JungHee threw me for a loop. He recorded his mp3 on a music editor, noticed the patterns of the “p” phonemes in his reading, and seemed to be able to notice sound more by seeing it in the digital soundwaves - doing a spectrographic analysis, basically - than by hearing it unaided by technology. So he shared by uploading his discovery, which I do here as well:

Here’s what JungHee said in his forum about this:

What I noticed in my sound wave was that there were frequent “high peaks”.
I posted the picture of this as attachment below for clarification..
All the “mountain looking” ones are the places where the “P” sound made the air go into the mic with too much force. So we can tell that there were some… “edged” words throughout the poem (?)

I don’t know what to make of this, but thought it was interesting to share.

Back to branding my student-people with tattoos for their permanent records….(*grrrr…*)

*This is all based on the conviction that one drawback of our multimedia age is that it has led to the atrophying of that mental muscle we call the imagination. That is not a good thing for our experience of the sublime and beautiful. And I love my student-people too much to deprive them of the opportunity to make the ascent to that plane.

If you like this post, please spread it: bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark (But don't tag it "education." That will bury it.)

  1. Using Screencast-o-matic to Deliver AP Literature Lessons
  2. Call for Crowd Wisdom: What Video, Photo, and Audio Archives Can Students Use for Mash-ups?
  3. An Invitation to Poetry: Interpreting Seamus Heaney’s "Clearances #5"

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

Written by Clay Burell

September 26th, 2007 at 3:13 am

2 Responses to 'How They Do Surprise Us, These People We Call Students'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'How They Do Surprise Us, These People We Call Students'.

  1. This is very cool, both the student and you noticing it.

    If he’s interested, google “plosive sounds” - those peaks are the bane of a sound engineer’s existence along with siblilance (hissing s sounds).

    There are whole industries devoted to managing those peaks he’s discovered. Actors who can control their own voice to lessen these peaks can actually make more money.

    Sylvia Martinez

    26 Sep 07 at 12:25 pm

  2. Ha! I actually replied on the Ning with the “plosive” word, which has lounged on the dole in my grey matter since studying post-structural linguistics way back in college.

    It’s nice to label phonemes for AP exams and other vital occasions.

    Interesting about the actors and sound engineers. When I started singing in a band a few years ago, I had my first experience of recoiling from my own mic-amplified plosives, and am still working on minimizing them :)

    Clay Burell

    26 Sep 07 at 12:37 pm

Leave a Reply

Note: This post is over 11 months old. You may want to check later in this blog to see if there is new information relevant to your comment.