One for the Learners: An Article on What a Real Literary Analysis Is
without comments
Print This Post
Clock’s ticking, but I look forward to sharing this with my high school students to show them the difference between a student-produced yawner of an unoriginal “literary analysis” and what real literary critics do when they write essays about a piece of literature. Here’s a snippet from the much longer article:
But the book is not a study in the varieties of critical engagement possible now, given our capacious theoretical toolkits. Harpham’s argument is that literary criticism is a distinct type of act performed by (and embodying) a specific type of agent. We don’t read criticism just for information, or to see concepts refined or tested. Criticism is, at its best, a product of “cognitive freedom,” as Harpham puts it.
“Interpretation represents a moment at which cognition is not absolutely bound by necessity to produce a particular result,” he writes, “…and this moment serves as a portal through which character, an individual way of being in the world, enters the work.”
The article is here.
If you like this post, please spread it:
(But don't tag it "education." That will bury it.)
- Now How Do We Get Our Learners to Have This "Encounter" with Literature in Our Classes?...
- 1001 Tales update: Scaffolding the Workshop, Making it Real...
- Risking Real Critical Thinking in School (or, "Beyond Critical Thinking About Safe Subjects")...
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.





